About Us
You Insurance Agency is an independent, locally owned agency at 257 Timber Dr in Garner, North Carolina — founded by Anthony You on a simple idea: insurance should feel like advice from a neighbor, not a transaction with a call center.
Prefer to talk it through with a real person? Call us at 919-341-0606 — we answer Monday through Friday, 8:30 am to 5:30 pm, right here in Garner.
Our Story
Anthony came to insurance as an entrepreneur, after building and selling a successful medical business. That experience shaped a clear vision: create a local agency that puts relationships ahead of policies sold — one that listens first, explains things in plain English, and picks up the phone when you call. Since then, our clients have made the case better than we could: 4.9 stars across 80+ Google reviews.
Independent Means You Come First
We don’t work for any single insurance company. As an independent agency, we shop the nation’s top carriers on every quote and every renewal, then recommend what’s genuinely best for you — whether that’s auto, home, life, or coverage for your business. When your rate creeps up, we re-shop it. That’s the whole point of working with us.
Meet the Team
Alongside Anthony, you’ll work with Joe Mesiti, a licensed agent with over a decade of industry experience; Laura Nance, a fully licensed property & casualty agent; and Shirley Tolentino, our office manager who keeps every policy and every client on track. When you call, a person from this team answers — not a phone tree.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where are you located?
257 Timber Dr, Garner, NC 27529 — and we serve clients across all of North Carolina. See our contact page for hours and directions.
What does it cost to work with an independent agent?
Nothing extra. Our compensation comes from the carriers, and because we compare multiple companies, clients typically save money working with us.
Let’s Take Care of You
Whether you need one policy or a full review, we’d love to earn your business the old-fashioned way. Insure with You!